Lee, one of apples lawyers, that he must be smoking crack if he thought apple. Verdict in applesamsung trial may echo through tech industry. Among those testifying is susan kare, who designed the icons for the original mac. Court of appeals reconsider the damages amount that samsung owes. On the sixth day of the samsung apple trial, deeply granular elements of. The applesamsung court battles expand to iphone 5, galaxy. Judge lucy koh may have hit the limit of her patience in the applesamsung trial thursday when she suggested a lawyer for the ipad maker. Samsung lawsuit to drag into eighth year with retrial scheduled next may. Windows phone as a platform needs to be remembered too. According to its trial brief, samsung will argue that apple is a relatively new player in the mobile market thats using decades of samsung research without paying for it or entering into. Apple versus samsung case goes to california jury update apple attorneys harold mcelhinny, foreground, and william lee walk to a federal courthouse in. Apple versus samsung patent trial comes down to the meaning of a threeword phrase apple vs samsung comes to a close, jury set to make decision on monday subscribe to 9to5mac on youtube for more.
Samsung patent trial is well underway and its not without its fair share of drama. Frustrated judge in apple versus samsung trial asks. Susan kare, creator of the icons on the original macintosh, testifies for apple at a trial to determine samsung patent infringement damages. A federal court on monday delayed closing arguments by one day in the patent infringement trial involving apple and samsung because of. Samsung countersued, and the case went to trial in august 2012. After three days of deliberations, the jury reached a unanimous verdict in the apple vs. It had alleged that apple was violating two of its patents. The case was filed in 2011 and went to a 2012 jury trial, which. Everything you need to know about the apple vs samsung trial day 6 by jose fermoso 5. Samsung back to a lower court in san jose, california. The trial in 2012 focused on how much samsung should pay for infringing apple patents covering aspects of the iphones design. Apple is going after samsung because that is where the profits are and. Judge koh asks apples attorneys if theyre smoking crack the verge.
The patent case between apple and samsung over the fate of. What are the implications of the verdict of the apple vs. In one of the most anticipated patent trials in recent memory, samsung and apple have been facing off against each other in a san jose courtroom for weeks. Judge lucy koh has been getting increasingly terse with both apple and samsung as the trial continues, and she just let apple have it after. On august 21, the wellknown trial between the tech giants is coming to an end. Samsung galaxy s9 plus vs iphone x sparkling water freeze test. Apple trial documents reveal early iphone and ipad prototypes. The trial will be limited to the same evidence used in the original trial, which means neither samsung nor apple can introduce new information. Samsung trial the verge liveblogged phil schillers testimony, and some of his remarks were revelatory. Apple sued samsung in april 2011 for slavishly copying the. Samsung, youre making it really hard for us to defend you. Claims of iphone envy, tampering with evidence and leaks to the media abound and that was just in the first week. Smoking crack and other quotes from applesamsung trial judge.
Everything you need to know about the apple vs samsung. Samsung patent trial ends with a partial victory for apple, but far from what it wanted. After 3 weeks of testimony and 3 days of deliberation, the jury in the samsung vs. What will be the outcome of the samsung vs apple trial. A federal appeals court says its up to a district court to decide if there should be a damages retrial in the longrunning patent case.
Applesamsung patent trial puts designers on the hot seat. A verdict has been reached and quite quickly in the trial between samsung and apple one of the biggest patent battles of its kind. Samsung moves right along and still manages to maintain the. Samsung patentinfringement battle is finally over well at least until its appealed. If apple prevails in its legal dogfight with samsung over patents. Apple versus samsung patent trial finally completely over.
I use none of their products both apple and samsung, but apple i. A jury on friday handed back a mixed verdict in the apple v. Rather, it results from samsung s deliberate plan to freeride on the iphones and ipads extraordinary success by copying their iconic designs and. Samsung case sat through an 18minute video explaining patent law before hearing apple s hourandahalflong opening. Today in the ongoing apple vs samsung court case judge lucy kohs patience wore thin as apple presented a 75page document highlighting 22 witnesses it would like to call in for rebuttal test. Apple and samsung hit each other hard tuesday during the opening statements of the patent trial between the companies, the associated press reported. By the time a decision is reached, theres a good chance both. Samsung may have been treated unfairly when the trial s magistrate judge refused to admit new evidence into the case late in the game despite the fact it had allowed apple to order an earlier. Apple versus samsung case goes to california jury update. Jurors awarded apple the verdict in federal court in san jose, california today.
Closing arguments delayed in applesamsung trial update. Apple hasnt managed to get samsung s key products banned in major markets, apple hasnt collected a penny of damages from the highprofile first u. I did it a couple of years ago and didnt expect it to become such a major success. The verdict comes after less than three full days of deliberation in a highstakes trial overseen by u. A nineperson jury sided with apple on a majority of its patent infringement claims against samsung. Jury sides with apple in longrunning samsung patent case. Supreme court gives samsung a reprieve in apple patent. Apple vs samsung trial, now in its third week of proceedings, is a very interesting source of information related to the mobile ecosystem that we follow closely here at android authority. Today in the ongoing apple vs samsung court case judge lucy.
The plethora of court cases between apple and other. The jury found largely for apple, ruling that samsung had willfully infringed on both apple. Apples patents include design elements as well as slidetounlock. Frustrated judge in apple versus samsung trial asks whether lawyer is smoking crack. Judge koh suggests apple is smoking crack in samsung case. Samsung trial couldnt get any more exciting, but somehow every day. Samsung lawsuit is getting a big reset, thanks to last years. Earlier, a developer can afford to ignore windows phones4% and develop for ios15% and android65% alone. Samsung managed to score a minor victory itself during the trial.
1076 611 829 1467 790 1212 1611 686 997 1189 193 986 1265 1197 834 525 689 712 810 905 402 985 1666 1379 472 485 685 1370 497 429 716 167 1280 1352 640 375 484 1091 39 154 1372 1055 1050 694 538 898 1265 1356